skip to main navigation skip to demographic navigationskip to welcome messageskip to quicklinksskip to features
  • Continue Your Membership
  • WEAC Member Benefits
All news

Janesville educator: 'Tis a shame (that education has become so political)

Posted: 2/22/2012 2:19:02 PM

Janesville social studies teacher Steve Strieker has received national attention with an article outlining his views on the attitudes of Wisconsin educators, given more than a year of extreme politics in the state that have largely centered on blaming teachers for the state’s fiscal problems.

The article, “’Tis a shame that education has become so political,” appears in the Washington Post’s “The Answer Room.” Strieker first posted the essay on his blog “One Teacher’s Perspective,” before the The Washington Post picked it up for national publication.

In the piece, Strieker writes about the assault on the education profession by Governor Scott Walker, whose legislation through ACT 10 prevents teachers from having a voice at the table when it comes to school decision-making. Coupled with state funding cuts of $1.6 billion for public schools – which at the local level has resulted in larger class sizes, fewer programs and staff reductions – Strieker outlines why many teachers are leaving the profession and more young people are foregoing careers in education.

The following is Strieker’s post excerpted at The full post is at

By Steve Strieker

In his 2006 memoir Teacher Man , the late, great Frank McCourt tersely wrote, “Teaching is the downstairs maid of professions.”

Just six years later, McCourt’s proposition is already in need of a rewrite. In Gov. Scott Walker’s Wisconsin, teaching has been relegated from professional status to political fodder.

Professional distrust reigns in the wake of Gov. Walker’s union-busting legislation created without consideration of professional educators’ input. Too many state and local business-focused politicians and their supporters have promoted unjust resentment for teachers, their unions, their compensation packages, their work conditions, and their professional standing. Many teachers fear what further awaits public educators in Gov. Walker’s Wisconsin.

Talented educators are prematurely retiring. Would-be educators are choosing new careers. Teacher morale is low. As a middle-aged educator recently said only partly in jest, “Every year since college I wished I was younger — until this past year. Now I suddenly wish I was older.” Many of us are too young to retire and too old to start a new (and more respected) profession.

Many midstream educators, like me, feel stuck. All the angst from this past year has left me wondering: Is teaching a profession?

Would politicians (such as Gov. Walker) employ aides to advise on business legislation who did not have professional business experience ? Why then is it acceptable for Gov. Walker to place non-educators in high-ranking education policy positions?

We do not need a teacher to explain the answers to these questions. In Walker’s Wisconsin, education is not a profession. It is politics.

In my 16 years of teaching, I have, like many teachers, advised dozens of promising students to join my noble profession. When I previously sized up prospective students for education careers, I evaluated their empathy, ethics, fortitude, leadership, maturity, interpersonal skills, and eagerness to learn before nudging them toward teaching.

With the current attack on public education, however, our next generation of professional educators will have to be seasoned young, impervious, and politically active. Otherwise, future educators will be doing more political initiatives in education, for less than professional pay, and with less professional liberties.

“‘Tis a shame,” McCourt might add.


Facebook Twitter Digg It! StumbleUpon

Post a comment

Read our Social Networking Guidelines

  1. Formatting options