SAGE Improves Achievement, Second Study Finds
A second major study of SAGE -- Wisconsin's ground-breaking class-size
reduction program -- again shows that it significantly improves student
achievement.
The Student Achievement Guarantee in Education program appears to be
"the most successful effort to date in closing the achievement
gap between black and white elementary school students," according
to a report on the study the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.
"This study again proves that the best solution we have to improving
academic achievement is not some complicated state government program
that funnels tens of millions of taxpayers' dollars into private schools,"
said WEAC President Terry Craney. "The best solution is much simpler
and more logical than that -- simply reduce class sizes in our public
schools so that the best teachers in the nation can give every student
the attention they deserve. Give our public schools the resources they
need, and they will accomplish amazing things."
The second annual study of the SAGE program was conducted by researchers
at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee and released by the Wisconsin
Department of Public Instruction.
"Common sense tells us that the more individual attention students
receive ... the more they will learn and the better behaved they will
be," state Superintendent John Benson said.
The SAGE program provides money to schools with large numbers of children
from low-income families. It is used to reduce class sizes to 15 students
in kindergarten through 3rd grade. The program is in operation in 80
schools throughout the state this year, and the study examined student
performance in the 30 schools involved in the program last year.
The study compared the achievement of SAGE students with that of a
comparison group of students who remained in traditionally larger classes.
It tested both groups at the beginning of the last school year (1997-98)
and again near the end of the school year.
The study, which echoes results of last
year's study, found that SAGE students consistently demonstrated
improved achievement, compared with their non-SAGE counterparts. Some
of the biggest gains were among African-American students, who typically
lag behind white students on standardized tests.
Among the results:
- 1st-grade students in SAGE classrooms achieved significantly higher
scores than their non-SAGE counterparts in all tested areas -- math,
reading and language arts.
- Students who were in 1st-grade SAGE classrooms in 1996-97 maintained
their achievement advantage in 2nd grade last year.
- African-American students in the SAGE program scored lower than
their non-SAGE counterparts before becoming involved in the program
but scored significantly better than their non-SAGE counterparts after
one year in the program.
- The biggest gains were among African-American students, signifying
the success of the program in closing the achievement gap between
white and non-white students.
The success of SAGE Below are mean scale scores of 1st-graders
in the SAGE schools compared to a control group of schools on
the 1997-98 Comprehensive Test of Basic Skills. Possible scores
range from 400 to 680 in language arts, 407 to 701 in reading
and 324 to 680 in math. |
| | SAGE schools | Comparison schools | Point difference |
| Language | 586.0 | 574.0 | 12.0 |
| Reading | 580.3 | 570.8 | 9.5 |
| Mathematics | 538.6 | 525.1 | 13.5 |
Total | 568.6 | 556.9 | 11.7 |
Posted January 24, 1999