THE MYTH THAT TEACHERS DONT WORK FULL-TIME
Private Sector Employment
In 1993 the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) conducted a
national study of employee benefits at medium and large private
establishments. The following data are from the Employer Benefit
Survey Bulletin #2456 which reports the results of the survey.
Hours Worked
Weekly work schedules of 40 hours predominate among full-time
employees. While some flex-time is being introduced, 82% of
employees work the standard 8 hours per day 5 days per week for a
total of 2080 hours per year. Most (96%) do not receive a paid
lunch, but two fifteen minute breaks are often provided.
Holidays
Nearly all full-time employees are provided paid holidays. The
average is 10 days per year including personal holidays
(e.g., birthdays) sometimes offered by employers.
Paid Vacation
Almost all full-time employees receive paid vacation. Vacation
averages 16.6 days for 10 years of service, and 20.4 days for 20
years of service. The BLS states that employees receive 15
or 20 days at 10 years, and 20 to 30 days at 20 years or more.
Teacher Employment
In 1996 the Wisconsin Education Association Council conducted a
statewide survey in Wisconsin which addressed teacher employment
conditions. The survey was sent to a random sample of teachers
statewide and was returned by 880 respondents. The following data
are from this survey on the Status of Wisconsin Teachers.
Number of Days Worked
The average number of school days reported by teachers was
180.9. Additionally, teachers reported an average of 6.9 other
contract days when they must report to school. Thus, the
average teacher is contracted to work 187.8 days per year.
Number of Hours Worked
By contract, the average teacher worked 7.66 hours per day.
However, teachers worked an average of 8.96 hours per week on
non-compensated instruction-related activity, like class
preparation and grading papers, after the school day was over
including weekends. Teachers also reported working an average of
6.06 hours per week in non-instructional related
activities. This category includes both compensated activities
like coaching and non-compensated activities like bus duty or club
advisor. When non-compensated instructional-related time spent
after the workday and non- instructional duties are added to the
regular workday, the average teacher is working from 9 to 10 hours
per day.
A Comparison of Private Sector Employees to Teachers
The comparisons below use data from the BLS Employee Benefit
Survey (1993) and the Status of the Wisconsin Teacher survey
(1996). For teachers the mean, or average, score for each response
was used in the left-hand column and the median score was used in
the right-hand column. One-half hour was subtracted from the
length of the contract day for lunch in order to calculate the
total number of hours worked per year by teachers.
Private sector hours were based on an employee who has 20 years
experience. This is an apt comparison since the average teacher
has 17 years of experience. Private sector hours were calculated
with and without paid breaks since many but not all employees
receive paid breaks.
Annual Hours of Work
Teachers
|
Mean Scores |
Median Scores |
|
Teaching days |
180.90 |
Teaching days 180.00 |
180.00 |
|
Other contract days |
6.90 |
Other contract days |
7.00 |
|
Hours per day (7.66 - lunch) |
7.16 |
Hours per day (8 - lunch) |
7.50 |
|
Instructional extra time (8.96 wk/5) |
1.79 |
Instructional extra time (7.3 wk/5) |
1.46 |
|
Non-instructional extra (6.06 wk/5) |
1.21 |
Non-instructional extra (2.39 wk/5) |
.48 |
|
187.8 days x 10.16 hours per day = |
187 days x 9.44 hours per day = |
|
Total: |
1,908.05 |
Total: |
1,765.28 |
Annual Hours of Work
Private Sector
|
Including Daily Paid Breaks |
Excluding Daily Paid Breaks |
|
(8 hours x 5) x 52 weeks = |
2080 |
(7.5 hrs per day x 5) x 52 weeks = |
1950 |
|
Holidays (10 @ 8 hrs) |
-80 |
Holidays (10 @ 8 hrs) |
-80 |
|
Vacation (20 days @ 8 hrs)* |
-160 |
Vacation (20 days @ 8 hrs)* |
-160 |
|
Total: |
1,840 |
Total: |
1,710 |
* Vacation is for a 20-year employee. The average teacher in
Wisconsin has 17 years of experience.
The most current data available show that Wisconsin teachers
work from 1,765 to 1,908 hours per year, not unlike their private
sector counterparts who work from 1,710 to 1,840 hours per year.
The similarity in hours between teachers and private sector
employees is due primarily to the extra time teachers spend
working with students and preparing for class after the typical
workday is over, in addition to the extra duties teachers are
responsible for after the regular workday.
In 1993 the average worker worked 39.2 hours per week, less
than the 47-50 hour work week for teachers.
In a related study on trends in hours of work, the Monthly
Labor Review stated that the average work week for
nonagricultural wage and salary workers was 39.2 hours, and that average
hours at work changed little over the period from 1976 to 1993,
increasing by just 1.1 hours (Rones, Llg, Gardner, April
1997). Within this relatively stable picture, however, two major
trends were notable. First, the proportion of people working more
than 49 hours per week is increasing. This group tended to work in
higher paying or sales related jobs. Second, the number of women
in the workforce is increasing as is the number of hours they are
working.
The increasing number of women, who work fewer hours than men,
and a decrease in the number of hours by workers under the age of
26 both helped offset the increase in the number of people working
more than 49 hours per week so that, in aggregate, there was only
a minor increase in the average number of hours worked between
1976 and 1993.
Women who teach work more than their private sector
counterparts.
In 1993, the average man worked 1,905 hours per year, and the
average woman 1,526. Female teachers, who comprise 70% of
Wisconsins teaching corp, worked about 239 more hours per
year than the average woman who worked in the private sector.
Related Facts and Talking Points
- Many teachers do not get paid during summer months and have
to budget for three months of no income. There is no comparison
in the private sector where gainfully employed individuals are
not paid for three month periods of time during their
employment.
- If teachers are paid during the summer, the monies paid are
monies which were earned at an earlier time and are being doled
out later with no interest.
- Many employees in the private sector who work more than 40
hours per week are entitled to overtime pay. However, teachers
who spend extra time helping students or preparing for class do
not receive overtime. The more time teachers spend helping
students the less their hourly wage becomes.
- The average amount spent by teachers last year for classroom
materials and/or to help meet the needs of students was $343.
About 33% reported spending more than $200 and six percent
reported spending more than $1,000 in the last academic year
(Status of Wisconsin Teachers, 1996).
- To maintain a license for employment, teachers must complete
six credits every five years. Studying, research, and class time
are all non-compensated additional time commitments which are a
requisite part of teaching employment.
- Over the last three years, from 29% - 40% of teachers took
college courses in any single year. Of these, teachers spent on
average $1,872 in tuition, books and fees; and 35% reported
spending between $1,500 and $10,000 in the last three years on
course work (Status of Wisconsin Teachers, 1996).
- On average, each teacher is responsible for 88 pupils per
day. However, 48% of teachers are responsible for 100-200
students per day (Status of Wisconsin Teachers, 1996).
- The majority of teachers are contracted to work an eight hour
day.
- The average teacher reported spending about 9 hours per week
on activities related to instruction after the workday was
over. Additionally, 42% of teachers reported spending more
than 10 hours per week, and 10% spent more than 20 hours per
week in post-workday instructional-related activities
(Status of Wisconsin Teachers, 1996).
|